Thank you for helping make FCC better. Bugs can be reported as GitHub Issues. Whenever reporting a bug, please check first that there isn’t already an issue for it and provide as much detail as possible.
I kind of like where you’re headed here. A coding challenge that consists of a code review? I think you’re on to something. I especially like the idea when there are really like ten different things wrong with the given code, that the fake-user is doing things really bass-ackwards but they work, except for one little thing. Do you point out the one little thing or do you tell him the whole thing is really bass-ackwards?
I think you put a challenge and you offer three solutions that are not working properly and invite the user to find the thing that they need to add or alter or change for the solution to work.
This will make the user memorize that solution because he’s going to read it a lot to figure out what’s missing and that way we are enriching coders variety of solutions and creativity.
And finally the score of the challenge is that how many solutions he can fix and made them work.
Of course you can put the best awkward thing if you want to add fun to it.
I believe just some challenges should be in this style, others should be like regular ones offered right now, i like them.