I think there may be an issue with the breadcrumbs example that caused me confusion.
The breadcrumb is:
Home / Electronics / Phones / Smartphone XYZ
This presents Phones as being inside Electronics. But the next example’s main navigation is:
Home | Electronics | Phones
This makes Phones appear to be a top-level item alongside Electronics. If Phones is actually a child of Electronics, shouldn’t the navigation reflect that hierarchy?
Your browser information:
User Agent is: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:156.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/156.0
Challenge Information:
User-Centered Design - What Are Best Practices for Designing Breadcrumbs?
One other thing stood out to me that may be an even bigger issue: the lesson says that breadcrumbs show “the path they took to get to the current page.”
But isn’t that different from what breadcrumbs are actually supposed to represent? If Phones is available directly from the main navigation, a user could click Home → Phones → Smartphone XYZ, while the breadcrumb could still be Home → Electronics → Phones → Smartphone XYZ.
So wouldn’t the breadcrumb be showing the page’s position in the site’s hierarchy, rather than the path the particular user took? If so, I think that wording could be quite confusing for someone learning how breadcrumbs work.
this can be a design choice, Phones is under Electronics, but the navigation exposes a link to it because it is a category of major interest, those this is not explained as it should
yes, this lesson talks about hierarchy breadcrumbs, which show the relationship of pages in the site
That makes sense. I was interpreting the navigation example as representing the same hierarchy shown by the breadcrumbs, which is what caused my confusion.
The distinction between the site’s hierarchy and which categories are exposed directly in the main navigation makes sense now. And I agree that the lesson could explain that more clearly.
Thanks for clarifying this and for creating the issue!