JavaScript newbie Help- Unreachable code

Been stuck on this.
Why does this not get evaluated and executed?

          if (position > 1){
            welcome = welcomeText2
            return welcome

function:

const customerData = {
 'Joe': {
   visits: 1
 },
 'Carol': {
   visits: 2
 },
 'Howard': {
   visits: 3
 },
 'Carrie': {
   visits: 4
 }
};

var myValues = Object.values(customerData);
var myObjects = Object.keys(customerData);

function isInside(array, target){
  var found = false;
  for (var i = 0; i < array.length; i++){
    if (array[i] == target){
      found = true;
    }
  }
  return found
}

function greetCustomer(customerData, name){
  var welcome = " ";
  if (isInside(myObjects, name) === false){
    welcome = `Welcome! Is this your first time?`;}
  for (let i = 0; i < myObjects.length; i++){
    var welcomeText1 = `Welcome back, ${name}! We're glad you liked us the first time!`;
    var welcomeText2 = `Welcome back, ${name}! I'ts good to see a regular customer`;
    if (isInside(myObjects, name) === true){
      var position = 0
      for(var j in customerData){
        position++
        if (name === j){
          if (position == 1){
            welcome = welcomeText1
            return welcome
          if (position > 1){
            welcome = welcomeText2
            return welcome
          }
          }
        }
      }
    }
  return welcome
  }
}

greetCustomer(customerData, 'Howard');

That if statement is inside another if statement that has a return.

if (position == 1) {
  welcome = welcomeText1;
  // returns out of loop
  return welcome;
  if (position > 1) {
    welcome = welcomeText2;
    return welcome;
  }
}

Thank you, I should have seen that. I edited and still could not get that if statement to trigger.

const customerData = {
 'Joe': {
   visits: 1
 },
 'Carol': {
   visits: 2
 },
 'Howard': {
   visits: 3
 },
 'Carrie': {
   visits: 4
 }
};

var myValues = Object.values(customerData);
var myObjects = Object.keys(customerData);

function isInside(array, target){
  var found = false;
  for (var i = 0; i < array.length; i++){
    if (array[i] == target){
      found = true;
    }
  }
  return found;
}

function greetCustomer(customerData, name){
  var welcome = " ";
  if (isInside(myObjects, name) === false){
    welcome = `Welcome! Is this your first time?`;}
  for (let i = 0; i < myObjects.length; i++){
    var welcomeText1 = `Welcome back, ${name}! We're glad you liked us the first time!`;
    var welcomeText2 = `Welcome back, ${name}! I'ts good to see a regular customer`;
    if (isInside(myObjects, name) === true){
      var position = 0;
      for(var j in customerData){
        position++;
        if (name === j){
          console.log(position);
          console.log(position > 1);
          if (position == 1){
            welcome = welcomeText1;
          if (position > 1){
            console.log('hello');
            welcome = welcomeText2;
            return welcome;
          }
          }
        }
      }
    }
  return welcome;
  }
}

greetCustomer(customerData, 'Howard');

Try removing all the returns from the if statements and just have the one return welcome at the end as you have now.

Edit: You still have the position if statements inside each other as well. Just some clarification if position equals 1 it can’t be greater than 1 as well.